The author states that there are some Coptic thinkers who are not satisfied with the deeds of Father Makary Younan as they accuse him of practicing charlatanism. Kamal Ghabriel, a Coptic thinker, describes Father Makary as a deceiver and calls to judge him. On the other hand, Hani Kamal Francis, who is interested in human rights, confirms that some people who suffer from psychological diseases come to him but are not necessarily cured.